August 1, 2025
·

Signs It’s Time to Find a New Payroll Company

The Wrapbook Team
Free ebook
Stop Wasting Time on Payroll
Download Now
Free Template
Download Now
About the author
The Wrapbook Team

The Wrapbook Team consists of individuals who are thrilled about building modern software tools for creators. We’re a team of compassionate and curious people dedicated to solving complex problems with sophisticated solutions. You can find us across the U.S. and Canada.

Follow the Wrapbook Team

Disclaimer

At Wrapbook, we pride ourselves on providing outstanding free resources to producers and their crews, but this post is for informational purposes only as of the date above. The content on our website is not intended to provide and should not be relied on for legal, accounting, or tax advice.  You should consult with your own legal, accounting, or tax advisors to determine how this general information may apply to your specific circumstances.

Last Updated 
August 1, 2025
See Wrapbook in Action

The next standard in production payroll and accounting is here.

Get Started

What to look for in a new payroll provider

If these issues sound familiar, it’s time for a provider that removes roadblocks instead of creating them. Here’s what to prioritize:

1. True digital solutions

Choose software that centralizes payroll, onboarding, and timecards in one platform—letting crew submit their own information and enabling you to catch errors before payroll runs.

2. Fast, repeatable onboarding

Look for features like reusable crew profiles, digital document templates, and eSignatures for I-9s, NDAs, deal memos, and more. The right system should make onboarding almost effortless.

3. Seamless integrations

Your payroll data should flow directly into your budgeting and accounting tools—no manual transfers. Integrations with software like QuickBooks, Hot Budget, or Sage Intacct are key.

4. Responsive, human support

You need both tech support for day-to-day issues and a dedicated account contact for bigger-picture questions—reachable by phone or email, with fast turnaround times.

5. Strong security

From encryption to third-party audits, your provider should safeguard sensitive payroll data and be transparent about how they do it.

6. Easy migration

Switching should be simple—especially with an EOR, which takes over tax and compliance responsibilities. Your provider should guide you through every step.

7. A commitment to innovation

A good partner listens to your feedback and evolves their platform to meet your needs—not just once, but continuously.

Wrapping up

Payroll will always have moving parts—but it doesn’t have to be slow, painful, or inefficient. If your current provider is holding you back, the right switch can save you hours per week and keep productions running smoothly.

Want to see firsthand how Wrapbook can make your production accounting and payroll experience a delightful one? Reach out for a demo to see our next-gen tech in action.

Production Payroll

Pay your crew—better. Smart timecards, real-time hours-to-gross.

See Feature

If your payroll “solution” is creating more problems than it solves, it’s time to rethink your provider. In production, payroll can be uniquely complex—but inefficiency, outdated tools, and clunky “digital” systems are not inevitable.

Spotting the signs early means you can make a switch before minor frustrations turn into full-blown production delays. Knowing when to retire a tool that’s no longer serving you is a skill—and one that can save you hours, money, and headaches.

Why production payroll demands a provider that exceeds needs

With crews moving from project to project, production companies are constantly hiring, onboarding, and paying a revolving cast of employees. One small error—whether in hours, union calculations, or compliance—can snowball into expensive, time-consuming fixes.

Even many “digital” payroll systems simply copy outdated paper processes into clunky online forms, creating a mess of inefficiencies that slow your team down.

Signs you’ve outgrown your payroll provider

If your payroll platform is holding you back, the first step is spotting the warning signs. Here’s where outmoded tools most often reveal themselves.

1. Outdated systems wearing a “digital” mask

Some payroll platforms appear modern but still run on outdated, patchwork processes under the hood. If tasks require multiple manual steps or constant re-entry of the same data, you’re dealing with inefficiency disguised as innovation. A truly modern platform automates these steps, freeing you from repetitive admin work.

2. One mistake = total do-over

A wrong location, hours, or employee number shouldn’t mean starting from scratch. Modern systems let you correct entries in real time without derailing your entire payroll cycle.

3. Data scattered across multiple platforms

Even with a solid payroll engine, if your onboarding, startwork, and payroll data live in separate systems, you’re stuck tracking down documents instead of managing productions. A unified hub keeps everything—forms, approvals, payment info—in one place, so you always know where to find what you need.

4. No integrations with accounting or budgeting

When payroll data doesn’t flow into your financial tools, you’re stuck manually transferring numbers—wasting time and inviting errors.

5. Slow, hard-to-reach support

On set, delays cost money. If your provider’s “support” is a dead-end email or hours on hold, it’s time to upgrade.

6. The burden of compliance is on you

Without an Employer of Record (EOR), you’re stuck registering crew in each state and handling all tax filings. EORs handle tax liability, workers’ comp, and compliance under their own federal ID—removing that weight from your plate.

7. A system that’s hard to learn and harder to teach

If it takes specialized training to use, payroll becomes bottlenecked through a few people—slowing everything down and frustrating new hires.

Stay In The Know

Sign up for the Wrapbook newsletter where we share industry news along with must-know guides for producers.

Book a Demo

Meet with a Wrapbook expert to create a plan for your payroll.